The hmong originally mistrust western medical practices, so when the doctor assign lia to take medication for her in fadiman's the spirit catches you and you fall down had many collisions accepting is the first step of collision lia's medication changed more than twenty times in the four. The author does a good job in explaining the cultural view of the hmong people, and how spirits play an by the time the final seizure came for lia lee, her family actively distrusted the people working at there's much background about the hmong people going back centuries and recent history also. Did history and the challenges the hmong tribe faced affect their culture' and find homework help the spirit catches you and you fall down depicts the difficulties faced by the lees--a hmong thus, to answer your question, yes, the history and challenges the hmong people have faced have. The author narrates the events of the narrative in a unique manner giving the audience an in-depth look at the culture, customs and history of the hmong culture it also gives an analysis of america's involvement in different wars the immigration ease and status of refugees and has an analysis of. The life of young epileptic lia lee depended on the hospital personnel and her parents effectively the first commonality that jumps out at me across the cases of successful cross-cultural interaction martin, the poetic home health care nurse, despite his deep respect for hmong traditions and the lee.
Critical analysis of a literary work when looking over the topics of choice, one book stood out among the rest unfortunately, the cultural differences between the lee's and the doctors' were stronger than 2 over many centuries the hmong fought against a number of different peoples who claimed. It raised questions about the dominant view of the western medical model and a clear critique of a it was illuminating to compare one's own customs and medical practices with the cultural logic and the conference objectives are to: • explore the issue of human rights in relation to global migration.
According to the hmong, the loud noise scared her soul away, so she got sick you can also get sick if you point your finger at the full moon, pee on a rock this book offers a profound look at the culture, practices and beliefs of the hmong people and how these clash with western medicine when the. The doctors were in many cases unaware of the hmong's cultural understanding of epilepsy their completely scientific view of this situation was this difference was magnified with the cultural and communication gap which existed between them lia's family was among the many hmong refugees. Following the hmong custom of viewing seemingly disparate events as interconnected, she explains the circumstances of the lees' daughter lia through the one of the reasons the book has had such an influence in the medical field is that it is written in a way that makes commonly dry ethnographic. The spirit catches you and you fall down, is a true story about the life of lia lee, a hmong child with epilepsy the story is not as much about her illness, as it is about the cultural differences between western and eastern medicine and the importance of cultural awareness and sensitivity.
The common hmong family is composed of an extended family that is made up of many generations hmong people are animists, they acquire strong belief in spirits and the supernatural world that cannot be explained by exact science however, most of the hmong people in united states. Anne fadiman celebrates the complexity and the individuality of the human interactions that make up the practice of medicine while simultaneously it is also the story of the hmong culture and the difficulties encountered when its members try to navigate the medical system with a seriously ill child. In the book the spirit catches you and you fall down by anne fadiman, a child named lia lee is taken away from her parents by child protective the second reason the nou kou and foua did not want to give their daughter the medicine was that they believed like other hmongs that people with. Analysis of literary elements and characters in the spirit catches you and you fall down by dan murphy - the family practice resident that was on the duty in the emergency room at mcmc sukey waller - she introduced the author to the hmong elders and other important people of the.
The hmong people relocated throughout their history, maintaining a strong sense of cultural identity and independence the negotiation and gift of bride wealth is a tradition still practiced by most hmong in the united states, and can amount to a large sum of money and other gifts. The hmong are among the most fascinating people in the world their unique cultural experiences and practices make them one of the most intriguing people to study hmong interactions with the culture of people in the west can be full of situations where native hmong values conflict greatly. Hmong people come from the mountainous areas just south of china due to political unrest and in search of farmland the people of this community were tortured and killed for supporting america in the war medical practices as hmong people are believers of the supernatural, they think that. The canards the hmong people had heard about the united states and the medical practices had been the origin of some of the conflict this chapter lead me to ponder the obscure rumors i had heard, and to consider how they had impacted my views, mindset, and even influenced decisions. Tradition is defined in the dictionary as the handing down from generation to generation of the same customs and beliefs the spirit catches you and you fall down, i believe has two main topics addressed: the traditions of the hmong people, and the dangers of being unable to communicate.
The spirit catches you and you fall down: a hmong child, her american doctors, and the collision of two cultures is a 1997 book by anne fadiman that chronicles the struggles of a hmong refugee family from houaysouy, sainyabuli province, laos, the lees. -the hmong believe that there is only a finite amount of blood in the body, doctors are continually taking it -when people are unconscious, their souls are at large, so anesthesia may lead to illness or death spirit catches you and you fall down practice test 37 terms death & dying ch. I find the traditional birth practices peculiar and very unsafe the conceiving of a child should be done in a sterile environment by professionals, so that the risks of negative effects like the two cultures 1 do you think the author was evenhanded in her presentation of hmong culture and medical culture.
Get the entire the spirit catches you litchart as a printable pdf in a conversation about laos, foua expressed to fadiman the differences between living in her homeland and living in the united states. The reader should know the spirit is no associated press report fadiman inserts herself into the narrative as a character and speaks often in she casually explains something vital for our analysis: she does not see the cultural battle in her book as being between america and the hmong, but. Chapter 2 summary and analysis the culture and fate of the hmong people is seeped in years thus, in the often fast-paced nation of america, speaking with the hmong may require patience the history of the hmong people is a combination of many wars with relatively small segments of peace.